Friendly Neighbor Epidemiologist

Share this post
Vaccines for 5-11 year olds
emilysmith.substack.com

Vaccines for 5-11 year olds

Dr. Emily Smith
Nov 11, 2021
23
18
Share this post
Vaccines for 5-11 year olds
emilysmith.substack.com

Share

My youngest got his COVID vaccine yesterday and we are officially on our way to being a fully vaccinated house. Whew, anyone feel a huge sense of breathing again? It was fairly emotional hearing how several of his buddies also got vaccinated.

I also saw from a Twitter friend that her child is scared of needles. But, he wrote his best friend’s name on a post-it note, took it with him to the clinic, and said his buddy’s name over and over while getting his vaccine. Why? His best friend is high-risk and he knew the connection of how his vaccine would protect his buddy.

Goodness, y’all. That’s collective solidarity right there. Kids are awesome and resilient and courageous.

Now onto the data…

There’s a TON of bad information about the vaccines for kids. Yuk, friends. Let me help sift through the disinformation and reassure you on the main points.

The vaccines for kids are safe, effective, and safe, effective and safe, effective. Don’t believe the dumb info circulating. People are being really sneaky in how they are packaging messages that, frankly, are lies and gross misinterpretation of the real data. Let me show you the real data…(all data is from the ACIP meeting unless otherwise noted).


First, let’s look at how COVID-19 in kids compares with other vaccine-preventable diseases.

COVID-19 is not a benign disease in children. Look at how it compares to other vaccine-preventable diseases regarding average deaths per year. For other vaccines our kids get when they are littles (like MMR), COVID-19 deaths are way higher. For example, look at deaths per year for Rotavirus (a yucky stomach bug). Prior to vaccines for Rotavirus, deaths per year averaged 20. Now compare to deaths per year for COVID-19 without vaccines for kids - it’s triple the risk. This should be a major take-home for all of us: COVID-19 places a risk of death for children without vaccines.

Next, let’s look at the epidemiology of COVID-19 in children. During the Delta phase, children are as likely to be infected as adults and can transmit as efficiently as an adult. Although rare, MIS-C (the severe complication of COVID-19) was more frequent among young kids 5-11 years.

Image

In children 5-11, COVID-19 was the 8th leading cause of death in the NCHS data. Whoa. This was also during the time that some mitigation measures were in place - so, the death toll would have likely been higher if these efforts had not been put in place.

Image

Sadly, hospitalization rates among children differ by race and ethnicity. We saw this with adult data too. The burden is not equal.

30% of kids hospitalized with COVID-19 did NOT have underlying conditions.

30% of kids hospitalized with COVID-19 did NOT have underlying conditions.

Friends, this is not a benign disease.

Image

Now that we’ve established the NEED for vaccines among kids, let me show you the data on the safety and efficacy of the vaccines.

I want to start with this slide about the benefits of vaccinating 5-11 year olds. Look at how many cases, hospitalizations, MIS-C cases (the scary complication of COVID-19 in kiddos), and deaths can be prevented. In our communities.

Take home: There’s a huge individual and population-level benefit of vaccinating our kids.

Image

LET’S HEAR IT FOR THE GRAPH!!

By now, we all are familiar with this graph. The blue line corresponds to infections among kids who received the placebo doses in the Pfizer trial and the red line are infections among kids who received the 2-dose kid vaccines.

Take home: A STRONG protection against COVID-19 is seen with vaccines. We saw this with the adult data too.

The graph shows the number of Covid cases recorded among the five to 11-year-olds who received a placebo injection (blue line) compared to those who were double-jabbed with Pfizer (red line). Just three Covid cases were recorded among the group of 1,500 children who received Pfizer, while 16 were recorded among the 750 who got the placebo jab. The researchers used this data to calculate that the injection was 90.7 per cent effective at preventing infection

What about side-effects?

Side effects were less frequent in kids than adults and mainly included a sore arm. My son had a sore arm the day of his first shot but nothing more today. No serious adverse reactions occurred in the trial.

The graphs show the prevalence of other side effects — including fever, tiredness and headaches — recorded among the two groups after each dose. Overall, 10.9 per cent of children vaccinated with Pfizer reported side effects, compared to 9.2 per cent of placebo patients. Tiredness and headaches were the most common side effects. And severe fatigue (0.9 per cent), headaches (0.3 per cent) and muscle pain (0.1 per cent) were reported after the first and second dose of Pfizer's injection. And 8.3 per cent of Pfizer recipients had a fever after the first or second jab. One person vaccinated with Pfizer had a fever exceeding 40°C two days after their second jab, but this went away the following day. No myocarditis, pericarditis or anaphylaxis was reported among any Pfizer recipients

I hope this helps alleviate some fears about these vaccines for children. They are safe, effective, and safe, effective. Don’t believe the crazy-town stuff circulating on the interwebs about them.

If you’re worried about long-term side effects and fertility issues (that’s one of the main disinformation circulating), go look at my post here. Scroll to the end to see why fertility is not an issue with these vaccines and long-term side effects shouldn’t be either.

***As a reminder, I do not respond or read comments on social media/email. However, I do respond and read comments here on Substack for paid subscribers. Thanks to everyone for the support and community as we keep navigating our way through this pandemic. If finances are a barrier to subscribing (less than a dollar a day), let me know! The science is always free. Subscribing help keeps the trolls and threats away from myself and family. =) And, supports the side-gig of mine with coffee and tea.

Love your (little) neighbors,

=)

-FNE

18
Share this post
Vaccines for 5-11 year olds
emilysmith.substack.com
18 Comments

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

Deanne Guthrie
Nov 11, 2021Liked by Dr. Emily Smith

We've already ordered our daughter her "Hug Me I've vaccinated shirt". She got her first dose Saturday. She has referred to it since before it was available for adults as the 'Hug Shot" Our daughter doesn't like shots but was eager *if not a little anxious;". She feels a huge sense of responsibility to protect not only herself but all those around her. How is my 8 year old smarter than a huge portion of the population?

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
1 reply
Amy
Nov 21, 2021

Hi, I appreciate the information you have provided and your work in putting out information that is accurate. However, I was hoping you would provide more scientific backing of the vaccines for 5-11 years old beyond what the CDC reports. Can you provide other scientific resources?

Also, can you speak to the argument going around about how more kids are being hospitalized from myocarditis following the vaccine vs covid itself? Can you provide some medical research that supports your view? I want to be done this pandemic just as much as anyone else, but I'm struggling with the risk vs benefit when it comes to my kids. What about other modes of treatment for Covid? If we know that monoclonal antibody treatment is effective, why isn't this being promoted more? Especially if the risk vs benefit ratio is potentially higher with this form of treatment versus the vaccine?

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
3 replies
16 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Emily Smith
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing